Tuesday, January 05, 2010

Nexus One versus iPhone 3GS

After Google announced Nexus One this morning, there have been several comparisons available on the Internet, e.g., Nexus One vs Motorola Milestone vs iPhone 3GS. This blog post is an attempt to compare the iPhone and Nexus One in tabular form.

iPhone 3GS
Nexus One
$199 (2-yr)
$79 (upgrade), $179 (2-yr), $529(none)
Nexus One is slightly cheaper.
Both are equal.
3.5", 480x320
3.7", 800x480
Pictures will appear crisper with the Nexus One: Larger resolution in almost the same real estate.
3MP, autofocus, no flash
5MP, autofocus, flash
Better resolution camera and flash!
VGA(640x480) up to 30 fps
720x480 pixels at 20 fps
Nexus One is inferior for motion (fps)?
600MHz CPU, 256MB
Qualcomm QSD 8250 1 GHz, 512MB
Faster CPU for Nexus One.
T-Mobile; Any, but no support for high speed packet access (HSPA)
Since the Nexus One comes unlocked, you can use any carrier. If data speed is important, stick with T-Mobile.
Accelerometer, digital compass, Assisted GPS
Accelerometer, digital compass, Assisted GPS
Both have similar characteristics.
Non-volatile storage
Built-in 16GB hard disk
Removable 4GB Micro SD (expandable to 32GB)
Expandability may be an advantage for Nexus One.
Built-in, 1219 mAH, Talk up to 5 hrs, Standby 300 hrs, Internet 5 hrs on 3G
Removable, 1400 mAH, Talk up to 7 hrs, Standby 250 hrs, Internet 5 hrs on 3G
Nexus One has slightly better capacity, is slightly better for voice, and slightly inferior for Standby.
Multitouch experience
Quite uniform
Not many apps exploit it (in Jan 2010).
Nexus One is inferior.
Peripheral interfaces
iPod connector, Bluetooth
mini USB, Bluetooth
Nexus One has no proprietary interfaces.
Software Features
Google Voice is still being evaluated.
All text fields can be spoken to.
All of Google software.
Nexus One may have an edge.

What is the bottom line? It is difficult to say without experiencing both the devices but, on "paper", Nexus One appears to have an edge, particularly if you ignore non-availability of multi touch experience uniformly in the Nexus One.

Mashable's Ben Parr provides a non-committal assessment at the CES.

Newer is better, isn't it?

Subsequently, we found out about Erik Chang's writeup comparing 4 devices:
Nexus One vs iPhone, Droid & Palm Pre
Find the best cell phone plans and more graphics at BillShrink.com
AppleInsider publishes another comparison: Nexus One vs. iPhone 3GS

1 comment:

  1. In the Switch from iPhone to Android ..., Jason Kincaid writes: "... Which brings me to the things that have turned me into a full-time Android user. Gmail on Android kicks the pants off of the iPhone’s Email client — something that I’m not the onlyperson to notice. As someone who does a lot of Emailing, that makes a huge difference to me. Google Voice integration is fantastic. The ability to run multiple applications at the same time is a breath of fresh air. Those three things were enough to seal the deal...."